Josh Dugan considers legal action after beating police charges

July 29, 2023 1:32 pm.by Staff Writer

In a stunning turn of events, former rugby league star Josh Dugan is contemplating legal action against the Sharks and the NRL after successfully defeating one of the main police charges that led to his abrupt sacking and the tragic end of his career. The saga began in 2021 when Dugan faced two police charges related to alleged breaches of the NRL‘s strict COVID-19 protocols.

The Sharks made the difficult decision to terminate Dugan’s contract with six weeks remaining, citing his alleged second biosecurity breach as the reason for his dismissal. The incident occurred during the lockdown period when Dugan was pulled over by the police near Lithgow, far away from his home in Gymea, Greater Sydney.

In a dramatic twist, Magistrate Kasey Pearce delivered a mixed verdict in Lithgow Local Court. While Dugan was found not guilty of the first charge, he was convicted of the second charge. However, his lawyer, Paul McGirr, swiftly announced plans to appeal the decision, vowing to fight for justice.

McGirr argued that Dugan was unaware of the constantly changing lockdown laws, which made it difficult for anyone to fully comprehend and follow them. The lawyer criticized the enforcement of these laws, suggesting that even the police were unclear about their application. In a compelling argument, McGirr contended that Dugan was in the process of relocating to another area, which potentially fell under different jurisdiction, when he was charged a second time.

The outcome of the court case has put the actions of both the Cronulla Sharks and the NRL under intense scrutiny. McGirr expressed his intention to seek compensation for the NRL’s hefty fine, considering that the court found Dugan not guilty of the initial offense that triggered this entire ordeal.

Moreover, McGirr criticized the NRL and other corporations for adopting a “guilty-before-proven-innocent” mentality, asserting that the approach should be the complete opposite. This stance implies that the NRL and the Sharks acted prematurely in terminating Dugan’s contract without waiting for the legal process to unfold.

The ramifications of the court ruling have potentially far-reaching consequences, not just for Dugan’s future but also for the NRL’s handling of disciplinary matters. As the former Blues and Kangaroos centre contemplates his legal options, questions arise regarding the fairness and transparency of the NRL’s decision-making processes.

In a career once filled with promise and talent, Josh Dugan’s journey has now taken an unexpected and tumultuous turn. His desire for justice and retribution against those who he believes wronged him will undoubtedly shape the narrative moving forward. As the rugby league community watches closely, the outcome of this legal battle could redefine the league’s approach to player conduct and discipline.

More sports news