NRL Wests Tigers face uncertainty amid Magpies allegations

A brewing controversy has surfaced within the Wests Tigers organisation, with allegations suggesting a push at the board level to revive the Western Suburbs Magpies.

The claims, made public by former Holman Barnes Group (HBG) chairman Tony Andreacchio, have raised concerns about the future direction of the NRL club.

Andreacchio, who represents the Tigers’ majority ownership group, reportedly sent text messages to several club members expressing unease about the “misguided ambition” within the organisation.

His messages, obtained by The Sydney Morning Herald, warn of potential moves to bring back the Magpies brand, jeopardising the existing Wests Tigers merger.

Currently suspended from board duties alongside two other members, Andreacchio faces a disciplinary hearing this weekend that could see him permanently removed from the board.

When contacted, Andreacchio declined to discuss the details of his messages but admitted to concerns about the club’s future.

“My only focus is on the best interests of the Wests Tigers,” Andreacchio told The Sydney Morning Herald.

“If I were a passionate Wests Tigers fan—which I am—I would be very worried about the future of the merger.”

Anonymous sources within the organisation have confirmed that a senior Tigers official approached Australian Rugby League Commission (ARLC) chairman Peter V’landys to express similar concerns.

These include claims that HBG director Dennis Burgess told Balmain chairman Danny Stapleton during a game this season, “We’re bringing back the Wests Magpies.”

The alleged comments have sparked fears of a potential split within the merger between the Western Suburbs Magpies and Balmain Tigers—a partnership formed in 2000 to create the Wests Tigers.

The Wests Tigers, currently a $34 hope for the 2025 season with the top online bookmakers, have declined to comment on the allegations, further fueling speculation.

Fans, already uneasy following years of underperformance on the field, now face uncertainty about the club’s future identity and leadership.

The internal turmoil comes at a pivotal time for the Tigers, who are undergoing a period of structural review and rebuilding under new leadership.

Any move to revive the Western Suburbs Magpies could have significant implications for the club’s stability and its relationship with the Balmain faction.

The disciplinary hearing for Andreacchio and his fellow board members is expected to shed more light on the situation, but for now, the Wests Tigers’ future remains clouded by boardroom division and uncertainty.

Sports news